New banks would be held to 10% of a building's ground-floor frontage on Miracle Mile. The Planning and Zoning Board also takes up guesthouses Wednesday, Nov. 18.
Coral Gables wants to keep new banks off most of the ground floor along Miracle Mile. The city’s Planning and Zoning Board reviews the change at 6 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18. It is one of four zoning code changes on the meeting agenda.
The board makes a recommendation only. The City Commission has the final vote, over two readings.
Overview
- Banks on Miracle Mile: new banks and other financial firms would be limited to 10% of a building’s ground-floor frontage on the Mile. They could still use upper floors.
- Guesthouses: any single-family lot could have one, not only estates of 1.5 acres or more.
- Flood zones: height for some apartment and townhouse buildings would be measured from the required flood elevation, not the ground.
- Yard signs: the five-foot setback from the street would go, and one more sign would be allowed at election time.
- When: 6 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, Community Meeting Room, Police and Fire Headquarters, 2151 Salzedo St.
Why the city wants fewer banks at street level
The city’s zoning code already says at least 90% of each lot’s frontage on Miracle Mile, at ground level, must be storefronts. Those are limited to retail, restaurants, art galleries, personal services, courtyards and building entries. Banks fit inside that 90% today, because the code counts a financial institution as retail.
The draft ordinance takes banks out of the retail definition. That leaves them with the remaining 10% of ground-floor frontage, shared with offices. There is no limit above the ground floor.
The new definition is broad. It covers:
- commercial banks and credit unions
- savings and loan associations
- mortgage lenders
- investment service offices and brokerage firms
- money service businesses
The ordinance says banks “traditionally generate limited pedestrian activity after business hours” compared with shops, restaurants and the arts. The city has spent heavily on the Mile’s streetscape and wants ground floors that bring people onto the sidewalk, the staff memo said. It said the change is meant to give small businesses room to “establish, grow, and succeed.”
A smaller version of a plan the board sent back
Staff first brought a wider proposal in April. It covered four business districts and would have required banks on prominent corners to add a cafe or another active use at street level. The board deferred it on April 15 after members raised concerns about those requirements in mixed-use areas, according to the memo.
The new version drops the corner and cafe rules. The ground-floor limit it sets applies on Miracle Mile. The city’s Economic Development Advisory Board recommended it unanimously on Sept. 2, the memo said.
The April staff report counted 51 active bank locations citywide. Of those, 29 were in the four business districts under review then. Among those 29:
- 26 were on a ground floor
- eight were on a ground-floor corner, seven of them in the Central Business District
That report said banks already operating legally would be treated as conforming uses. The new memo does not address existing locations.
Guesthouses on more lots
Today a guesthouse is allowed only on a “Residential Estate.” The code defines that as a single-family site of at least 1.5 acres, 200 feet wide and 250 feet deep. The guesthouse must also sit in the rear yard.
The guesthouse staff report proposes dropping both conditions, “based on comments and feedback from residents.” The other limits stay:
- no more than 600 square feet, or 10% of the main house’s ground area if that is larger
- a kitchen is allowed
- only nonpaying personal guests of the household may stay
- no guest may live there year-round
- an owner may not live in the guesthouse and rent out the main house
Setbacks and lot coverage rules for the zoning district still apply. Staff recommends approval.
Flood zones and building height
In the Multi-Family 3 district, townhouses and apartment buildings are capped at 45 feet, measured from the ground. Some of those lots are in a Special Flood Hazard Area. There, buildings must meet a required flood elevation that can sit above the ground, and that lift counts against the height cap today.
The flood height staff report would measure three stories or 45 feet from the required flood elevation plus freeboard, the extra margin above it. Space below that line could be used for parking or storage, as the Federal Emergency Management Agency allows. The change does not alter density or floor area limits, staff said. Staff recommends approval.
Yard signs
The board deferred the sign change in September. Board members discussed limiting the extra signs to election signs. The city attorney’s office raised First Amendment concerns, so the proposal comes back unchanged, according to the signs memo.
Under the September staff report, temporary noncommercial signs could:
- sit closer to the street, with no five-foot setback from the public right of way
- go on a front or side door, window or wall, or on a fence or wall facing the street
- number four per lot during an election period, up from three
The size cap of 22 by 28 inches and the 120-day limit stay. The election period still runs from 90 days before an election to five days after.
What it means for you
- If you shop or own a business on Miracle Mile: a new bank could not take a full storefront on the Mile if the ordinance passes. The draft lists a City Commission first reading on Dec. 15.
- If you have a single-family home: you may be able to add a guesthouse for visiting family without owning an estate-size lot. It would still need city review and permits.
- To comment: e-comments through the city’s Planning and Zoning Board page or email to planning@coralgables.com must arrive by the close of business Tuesday, Nov. 17. You can also speak in person or on Zoom, or by phone at 305-461-6769, meeting ID 837 8870 9513.
- To watch: the meeting streams on the city’s CGTV page and on Comcast Channel 77.
Have your say